One of the many puzzles you’ll need to solve during The Journey to Mêlée Island Tall Tale is constructing a new body for Murray. If you are looking for the Skeletal Right Arm required to complete this puzzle, you’ve likely already purchased the Chef’s Uniform and cooked the Root Beer Stewed Meat.
However, you’ll also need to steal the Clock Tower Key from a Thirsty Pirate in the Scumm Bar. Once you can access the Clock Tower, you can climb to the top and retrieve the Skeletal Right arm!
Where is the Skeletal Right Arm?
The Skeletal Right Arm is in the Clock Tower. It is jammed in the giant gears at the top, preventing the Clock Tower from working.
To gain entry to the Clock Tower, you’ll need to purchase the Chef’s Uniform, equip it, and serve the Extra-Potent Grog to the Thirsty Pirate that holds the Clock Tower Key.
Once you have poured him enough drinks, he will pass out, allowing you to take the Clock Tower Key.
Use it on the door beneath the Clock Tower and climb the stairs to the top! You’ll find the Skeletal Right Arm jammed in the gears. Interact with the arm, and it will pop out behind you. With it free from the gears you can pick it up and attach it to the skeleton!

If you are looking for the Skeletal Left Arm, you’ll find it in the Jail. You can find out more about where the Skeletal Left Arm is and how to get it here.