One of the many commendations you work toward as you siege an Ashen Garrison is the ‘My Cup Runneth Over’ commendation.
If you need help completing the rest of the Secrets of the Banished commendations, check out our entire walkthrough here.
If you are just looking to complete ‘My Cup Runneth Over’, you’ll first need sail over to King’s Chalice Garrison in The Devil’s Roar!
My Cup Runneth Over
To complete the My Cup Runneth Over Commendation, you must sell five Chalice Lighthouse Logs to The Reaper’s Bones.
You can find Chalice Lighthouse Logs inside the locked compartments of an emergent or on-demand King’s Chalice Garrison on the High Seas. The King’s Chalice Garrison Treasury has four compartments that you can open. To unlock a compartment, you’ll need to use an Ashen Key.
You can find Ashen Keys while you rummage through furniture in King’s Chalice Garrison. However, you should bring a few more to the Garrison to make sure you can open all four compartments.
You can find additional Ashen Keys by defeating:
- Ashen Key Masters during a Skeleton Fort World Event
- Emergent Ashen Guardians on islands
- Captain Skeleton Ships on the final wave of a Skeleton Fleet World Event
You are guaranteed to find at least one Chalice Lighthouse Log in the King’s Chalice Garrison Treasury, so you’ll want to collect four Ashen Keys so you can open all four compartments. While you can always find one Chalice Lighthouse Log, you do have a small chance of finding more.
Once you have a Chalice Lighthouse Log, you can sell it to the Servant of the Flame on The Reaper’s Hideout.
